If you could sneak into the Jets' facility late at night and steal a sleeping Jets player—please ignore the enormous plot hole at the center of this question, if you would—who would be your selection?
Despite their deserved reputation as a national punching bag thanks to poor quarterback play, the Jets have some terrific players, particularly on the defensive side of the ball. They added first round pick Leonard Williams to a defensive tackle rotation that includes Sheldon Richardson and Muhammad Wilkerson. They also have Darrelle Revis, talented receivers Eric Decker and Brandon Marshall, and even gifted power back Chris Ivory. Quality choices abound, so long as you look away from QB.
I'd have a tough time passing up Muhammad Wilkerson, who has provided consistently phenomenal run stopping without the legal troubles that have accompanied Sheldon Richardson. I like Paul Soliai just fine, but parking Wilkerson next to Ra'Shede Hageman, Grady Jarrett, and Jonathan Babineaux would hover around unfair.
Who is your choice?