The Pre-Super Bowl Trade: A Hypothetical Discussion
I was watching the NFC Championship with my dad last night and we were flabbergasted that despite how badly the 49ers wide receivers were playing (1 catch total for 3 yards), they were two Kyle Williams gaffes away from reaching the Super Bowl. With that defense, Frank Gore, and the suddenly-competent Alex Smith, the Niners would be unstoppable if they had just one decent receiver to complement Vernon Davis. That's when we got this idea.
We all know the first week of the two-week Super Bowl run-up is the worst of the two, and the 30 other fan bases that are sitting on the outside are all a little bitter and bored. So I introduce to you the Pre-Super Bowl Trade. Here are the rules, after the jump:
- During the week following the Championship games, the two Super Bowl teams are allowed one trade with another team in the league (except the other Super Bowl team) to improve their roster
- The trade must be players only, up to 3 players from the Super Bowl team for one player on the trade partner team, and the new player must fit inside the team's salary cap for that year
- If a team makes a trade with another team, that team also surrenders their first round pick in the following draft as a 'Trade Tax' (the first round pick does not count as value in the trade)
- The player on the trade partner team being traded has a right to refuse and kill the deal.
Can you imagine how much fun this would be? What if the Niners had won the NFC Championship, and then offered to trade OT Joe Staley, DB Carlos Rogers, and their 31/32 1st round pick to the Falcons for Roddy White? Would Atlanta do it? Would Roddy go? Would that help them win the Super Bowl?
So because we've got nothing to do this week but feel a little down while listening to press on the Pro Bowl and fluff pieces on New England and New York players, let's pretend we're all GMs in this hypothetical world where the Pre-Super Bowl Trade exists. What trades should the Giants and Patriots make, with whom, and why? Would you want them to trade with the Falcons, and what would that trade be (remember that these trades have to benefit the Super Bowl team)? Also, imagine that the Falcons were in the Super Bowl in place of the Giants. What trade should the Falcons make, if any?
This FanPost was written by one of The Falcoholic's talented readers. It does not necessarily reflect the views of The Falcoholic.
7 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Hate the idea
think of it this way, you’re on the team, playing whatever your role is (let’s say a linebacker that plays 15% of the snaps), and you’re on the NFC championship team.
Then on Monday, head coach calls you in, informs you that you’re not going to the super bowl, you’re being traded away. I know NFL is a business, but I can’t think of a single way in which that doesn’t seem “wrong”, to say the least.
It's Great! To be! A Tennessee Vol!
Naturally
the catch would be that the players that were traded away would still get a ring or some kind of compensation. That would be cruel and unusual punishment otherwise.
It’ll never happen, though. Roddy can’t learn what he needs in an offense in a week or two. Nobody can.
Follow me on Twitter! twitter.com/FalcoholicZippo
If you're a fan of the Falcons, or if you want to chat it up with some Falcons fans, sign up here, share your opinion, and get to know some great fans of the Falcons!
by Caleb Rutherford on Jan 25, 2012 12:20 AM EST up reply actions
it's not even the ring or compensation
isn’t it “every kid’s dream” to play in the super bowl? lifelong dream for every player in the NFL, I’m sure.
It's Great! To be! A Tennessee Vol!
Actually
what would make this REALLY fun is if the player that was traded away still got to play in the Super Bowl and then departed for the new team after the SB was over, but they still got the player they traded for, too.
Follow me on Twitter! twitter.com/FalcoholicZippo
If you're a fan of the Falcons, or if you want to chat it up with some Falcons fans, sign up here, share your opinion, and get to know some great fans of the Falcons!
by Caleb Rutherford on Jan 26, 2012 10:58 PM EST up reply actions
Who could also play in the SB (the player they obtained)
Follow me on Twitter! twitter.com/FalcoholicZippo
If you're a fan of the Falcons, or if you want to chat it up with some Falcons fans, sign up here, share your opinion, and get to know some great fans of the Falcons!
by Caleb Rutherford on Jan 26, 2012 10:59 PM EST up reply actions
Worst idea in a long time
This sounds fun, I agree, but in truth it would be the biggest waste of everyone’s time. You have to realize the players on these squads have been preparing and crafting their skills to match the schemes ran by each team all year long. You can’t take a player out of one offense and drop them into a new one, only to give them 2 weeks to learn EVERYTHING. Same goes for defense. It’s just not realistic whatsoever. Not to mention the camaraderie that has been forged amongst the players on a team throughout the28 weeks of preseason and regular season. Bringing a new wolf into the pack right before a hunt is only going to cause problems. This whole idea would cause far more issues than it could solve.
Somebodys been playing Madden too much...
If Halladay, Lee, and Hamels all break their arms while playing tag in the clubhouse, We'll be set
by suicide bunting is a sin on Jan 31, 2012 3:57 PM EST reply actions

by 














