Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Newcastle Battle Injury Woes Ahead of Tottenham

Why Doesn't The NFL Celebrate Player Celebrations?

In my sports-watching career, there are some iconic moments that stand out that have nothing to do with the game on the field. There's the Dirty Bird, of course. There's the Ickey Shuffle. And then there's Chad "Ocho Cinco" Johnson's finest moment.

For those of you who don't remember, the oft-fined Johnson celebrated a touchdown in a unique way back in 2003. With snow banks dotting the field, Johnson had apparently taken the time to stash a sign beforehand, because after the score he hauled out an orange sign that read "Dear NFL, please don't fine me again!" It was a hilarious thing to watch, but you knew the outcome before it even happened. He got slapped with $10,000 in expenses for what amounted to a clever and harmless joke.

This is all too common, now.

The NFL's stern and angry taskmasters have taken the art of the celebration out of the NFL. Whether they cite safety concerns as they do for those bringing items into the stadium (cell phones and Joe Horn), showing up the opponent (Terrell Owens dancing on the Dallas Cowboys' midfield star) or anyone having any kind of fun (the Houston Texan follow up to Horn's celebration), the league has clearly taken a stand against celebrations of any kind. I guess I understand the thinking, but all I really see is the NFL depriving players of a chance to be creative and innovative in any way. I also understand that some people don't care about or completely loathe these celebrations, but I do think they're kind of a blast. Of course, the NFL itself would counter with talk of professionalism, uniformity and safety. When you have the power that league does and you're holding guys by the pay check, you can do whatever you want.

But why do we have to be uniform and bland? The league is filled with exciting, dynamic people, different people, who are being forced to wear exactly the same color socks and speak in the same bland platitudes. When players whine about that, they get slammed for being whiny, crazy millionaires. But is that what we want as fans? Does anyone like listening to Bill Belicheck drone his way through a postgame interview without once saying something insightful? Are we thrilled that not one player can tell us something that's more advanced than 110% effort and play the game the right way? Am I the only one baying at the moon about the fact that the league--and sometimes we fans--go out of our way to squash the quirky personalities in the league?

Maybe I am. But I can't help but think back to the day when Chad Johnson waved his sign defiantly at the cameras, a harmless gesture, a humorous David taking on a grim-faced Goliath. I can't help but think about the NFL's reaction to that, and a subsequent crackdown that stuffs everything outside of the huddle into a square hole. And at the end of this particular day, I can't help but believe, as I always have, that being a fan is still about having fun and enjoying the game of football.

Maybe I'm alone there, too. What do you think?

Comment 34 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Here's what I want to stop:

Celebrating after every single play, like when a defensive player breaks up a pass. Yes, great, you stopped the play. THAT’S YOUR JOB. Wait until you intercept the ball and take it back twenty yards before you spend fifteen seconds hooting and hollering.

I do see your point. I guess the post-play celebrations are an after-effect of the players being neutered in the endzone. About the most players can do now is hold up a hand to the sky, fall to one knee as if in prayer, or clap a teammate on the back…or, like Matty Ice, run all the way down the field and launch yourself on top of another player.

You have opinions. Share them.

by Adam Schultz on Jul 27, 2009 8:34 AM EDT reply actions   1 recs

the knee...

going to the ground isnt that part of an illegal celebration? Thought it was any body part that touches the ground.

by Mr International on Jul 27, 2009 5:06 PM EDT up reply actions  

touchdowns

yes, I understand and actually am ok with. escpecially if they put you in the lead. but just doing it for the purpose of self promotion, yeah I can do without it.

Life is a garden. Dig it!

by Hardcore Falcon on Jul 27, 2009 8:37 AM EDT reply actions  

That's basically my point

In much, much more concise terms.

Sign up for a free account today to join the discussion about all things Atlanta Falcons!

by Dave Choate on Jul 27, 2009 4:58 PM EDT up reply actions  

Classless...

I agree with tloz’s perspective on the annoying nature of celebrations on every single play. It would be like me celebrating after I send an e-mail at work (which I do, and it’s annoying to everyone else). Sure you should be happy and excited about your success, but please control yourself – you look much cooler if you act like it’s not out of the ordinary for you to make a play.

As far as touchdowns go, it seems unsportsmanlike and disrespectful to the other team to put on a big, theatrical display (a la Baseketball <- great movie). Again, I understand that it’s exciting, and there is nothing wrong with high-fives, etc…, but the best athletes play it cool because they know they are just doing their job.

by TomQ on Jul 27, 2009 8:56 AM EDT reply actions  

Exactly

As an ND fan, my favorite quote about end zone celebrations comes from Lou Holtz: “Act like you’ve been there before.” I would hope the football teams I root for have enough class to do that, instead of putting on “Future Hall of Fame” jackets or making snow angels.
I can understand being excited to score a touchdown, but showboating about it is never ok.

Its true. I'm a Falcoholic! I just can't live without Falcohol!

by phoenix falcoholic on Jul 27, 2009 9:03 AM EDT up reply actions  

I like the celebrations

Yeah celebrating after every first down or every tackle is annoying but after a big play or a touchdown I like it. Nothing too excessive though. Some of my favorites are when Steve Smith slid down the goal post or T.O. signing a football and throwing it to a fan, that didn’t show anybody up and think how happy you would be if you got to take home a Roddy White autographed football. I understand the NFL not wanting one player to rub it in the face of an opposing player and get tempers flaring but a harmless dance in the endzone shouldn’t be against the rules

by FLA_Falcon on Jul 27, 2009 10:17 AM EDT via mobile reply actions  

Yeah, the one guy...

out of 90,000 loved it. T.O. has got the biggest ego I’ve ever seen. He’d be so much more likable if he didn’t pull crap like that and let his play do the talking. What if the entire team had signed the ball and threw it into the crowd? When is it too much? Hey look at me! I scored a touchdown all by myself!

I love White, but I want to barf every time I see that picture on the Sports Illustrated Falcons team site with him exposing his “Free Mike Vick” shirt after a touchdown. God, I wish they would update the pictures on that site.

Okay, sorry, my rant is over now.

by TomQ on Jul 27, 2009 10:30 AM EDT up reply actions  

Never mind...

My rant is not over. When a guy plans his celebration ahead of time (i.e. bringing a sharpie to the game in your sock), it demonstrates your lack of focus on the game itself (“Man, I’ve gotta get a touchdown soon or this sharpie might start bleeding in my sock!”). Also, it should be noted that T.O. gave the ball to either his agent or his financial advisor, not some random fan.

Now my rant is over.

by TomQ on Jul 27, 2009 10:37 AM EDT up reply actions  

Celebrations

Celebrations started within the context of the game and for a large moment in the game and were mostly spontaneous. They evolved into orchestrated celebrations of largely personal accomplishments which exaggerated individuals accomplishments at entirely inappropriate times in the game and for actions which deserved no notice at all. The individual culture in the NFL has run amok on some teams and players.

My favorites are when a D players celebrates his one “big” play when he is down 20 and hasn’t stopped the opposing offense all day or when the receiver makes a first down grab and signals the first down when he is down 20. Gimme a break.

by Whopper Dawg on Jul 27, 2009 11:23 AM EDT reply actions  

You might get along with Jack DelRio...

Your second paragraph describes the situation which led to his fall out with our own Mike Peterson (Essentially, the Jags were down by about 20 point and Peterson made a sack, and then, upon getting up, flexed his muscles). While I might be biased, I actually thought Peterson’s explanation – that he was trying to fire his teammates up – was pretty understandable. I guess that argument could be used for a lot of the little, small play celebrations. I obviously can’t decide which side of the issue on on here :) I guess the difference is between showboating and just being excited and fired up, the latter of which is hard to avoid.

by TomQ on Jul 27, 2009 11:59 AM EDT up reply actions  

lol free Mike Vick

That was pretty ridiculous. I understand where you are coming from with the premeditated celebrations, but football is a game, games are meant to be fun. Yeah the No Fun League is a big money machine but that’s because the fans pay to see it. I like to see the guys have fun, if I wanted to watch a bunch of robots play football I’d go dig my dads electronic football set out of the attic. At the same time I understand not everyone feels the same as I do, players shouldn’t celebrate every single play but every now and then why not have some fun?

by FLA_Falcon on Jul 27, 2009 12:06 PM EDT via mobile reply actions  

CELEBRATIONS...

Should be allowed for touchdowns for every team to have their own certain type of team celebration- ie the lambau leap- not flagged by the refs -(we got the dirty bird) so every team has their own thing they do after scoring a td, therefore we celebrate TOGETHER as fans and a team. then we can try and get rid of all the nonsense celebrations that guys pull out for making plays they are supposed to make and are paid to make!! ie -shawn merriman. But could you imagine it being so funny when ANY falcon player scores they HAVE to do the dirty bird – matty ice, a DT, etc.. hillarious!!

by ATLsince1972 on Jul 27, 2009 1:20 PM EDT reply actions  

I think the key thing here

Is sportsmanship, which is something I only touched on in the article. Terrell Owens dancing on the Cowboy star is pretty darn close to disrespectful, and getting up and screaming in a guy’s face could be.

What I’m arguing for is the fun stuff. Tell me a situation in which Chad Johnson holding up that sign or the Texas pretending to look for a cell phone in the goalpost is any way harmful or showing a team up. It’s amusing, and I’m sure the players themselves get a kick out of it. For the NFL to fine guys who are doing something creative that doesn’t even reach the level of a guy jumping and screaming after big tackle is complete nonsense to me.

Sign up for a free account today to join the discussion about all things Atlanta Falcons!

by Dave Choate on Jul 27, 2009 3:25 PM EDT reply actions  

I respect your point of view (as always)...

and admittedly, celebrations are entertaining sometimes, but I think it’s a distraction from the game which players and fans care deeply about. I know a lot of people (especially down here in SEC country) who prefer college football over pro because to them it is much more pure – and I can see their point (though I prefer the higher level of skill and athleticism offered by the NFL).

I never played football, unfortunately, but I play soccer (not unfortunately). If the opposing team scored a goal and then went over the the fans and started signing autographs or doing some other “funny” display, I’d be pretty riled up. Let’s get on with the game…that’s just my perspective.

You will never see a classy person, like Matt Ryan, partaking in any “creative” celebrations. He’ll get fired up and congratulate teammates, etc., but he’d never (I’ll put money on that) do some goofy celebration.

by TomQ on Jul 27, 2009 4:30 PM EDT up reply actions  

I respect what you're saying, as well

But I think the NFL is shooting itself in the foot on this. For a juggernaut that rolls up business like Katamari Damacy, they’re going out of their way to shut something down that I don’t find in any way offensive and probably attracts casual fans or non-football fans who might give the sport a chance if they see an amusing highlight.

The game can and will go on without them, and obviously I wouldn’t miss them that much if everyone just clanked and clicked their way through the game with no emotion at all. I just prefer to think of the athletes I’m watching as human beings, and lord knows human beings like to celebrate their achievements.

Sign up for a free account today to join the discussion about all things Atlanta Falcons!

by Dave Choate on Jul 27, 2009 4:57 PM EDT up reply actions  

Seems like it's just a preference...

Honestly, TD celebrations aren’t something I’ve thought a whole lot about – although I have been annoyed by the seemingly endless chain of celebrations after every single play. I guess it’s a matter of perspective and preference. In the end, it’s really not that big of a deal, I guess. I just think pre-meditated celebrations show a lack of focus on the game, and promotes a sense of individualism over team, and represent overgrown egos. On the other hand, they can be entertaining, creative, and funny. Interesting topic – glad you brought it up!

by TomQ on Jul 27, 2009 7:41 PM EDT up reply actions  

I usually

don’t like Chad (Ochocinco) Johnson and his antics, but I enjoyed the Riverdance celebration. I agree with most commenters so far that the celebrations after every single play are getting out of hand, and are much more annoying than a celebration after a TD. The thing is that the fines ($5-10 thousand) are chump change to these guys – if they want to celebrate so bad, go ahead – just pay the fine.

by orang3b on Jul 27, 2009 4:52 PM EDT reply actions  

Loved the riverdance....

watched it over & over laughing repeatedly. But some of my fav’s are Steve Smith rowing the boat to get away & whoever gave CPR to the football. I also think that when the Rams used to do their touchdown celebration it hyped the WHOLE team up. So when the league took that…it took a piece of them. They havent been the same since.

by Mr International on Jul 27, 2009 5:12 PM EDT up reply actions  

I'm glad you brought this up...

I hated when this happened (just the safety I mean), but this youtube video cheered me up

know what you believe in and why you believe in it

by MentallyMIA on Jul 28, 2009 12:01 AM EDT reply actions  

Old School

The reason the NFL will always fine players for their unsportsmanlike celebrations is they are protecting the integrity of the game. Football is more than just a game. It teaches kids valuable life lessons about teamwork, respect, integrity, and sportsmanship. How can kids ever learn these lessons watching grown men embarrass themselves with “look at me” antics during every game? There is good reason that crap doesn’t fly in every other level of football. It shows a true lack of character, and sportsmanship at it’s worst. Playing in the NFL is a privilege not a right. Go join the WWE if you want to put on a show. True fans of the game appreciate the GAME not the celebrations. Go ask any old school NFL hall of famer what they think about it. Vince Lombardi is rolling over in his grave. Unfortunately, this crap will continue until they make the fines higher and tack on a suspension. The only good thing that has ever come out of these celebrations was when George Teague knocked T.O. on his self-absorbed ass while he was disrespecting the Cowboys star.

by Zaner45 on Jul 28, 2009 4:26 AM EDT reply actions  

Old School

I have to admit that seeing T.O. get demolished when he tried to celebrate on the star for the second time is pretty spectacular. But I do have to disagree with you on one of your points, I don’t believe that a celebration shows a lack of true character. Look at the Washington Huskies game vs. BYU last year, a 21-22 year old kid runs in for the game winning touchdown and in a moment of pure elation tosses the football in the air. This is not done to disrespect the other team, this is not done because he wants to rub it in anyone’s face. He is really freakin’ excited. I think that there is something to be said about certain celebrations. I’ll agree with you that orchistrated celebrations like a player machine gunning down his teammates sends the wrong message, but I don’t see how someone doing the Dirty Bird or poking fun at the league hurts anyone. If you’re in the stands at an ATL game now, look around after the Falcons score a TD, the majority of fans in the stands are doing the Dirty Bird, why can’t a player? I am “true fan” who appreciates the GAME, as you would say, and I certainly appreciate it when Roddy White does a flip after scoring a TD or the two wrecking balls out of Carolina do their Matrix thing or whatever. There is a difference between tasteless celebrations and ones out of honest exuberance.

Just my thoughts.

"If you can’t get excited for Ryan throwing to Gonzalez, you’re either a robot or clinically dead. Or you’re a zombie robot, which is just plain awesome."
Dave the Falconer

by Pregame with Pabst on Jul 28, 2009 10:56 AM EDT up reply actions  

Good point about that college game...

That “excessive celebration” call was terrible!

by TomQ on Jul 28, 2009 2:22 PM EDT up reply actions  

Loosen up

I say bring back the old days of the Fun Bunch, the Ikkey Shuffle, the Dirty Bird, the Gastineau Sack Dance, hell even ol Billly WhiteShoes had a dance going there for a while. I honestly used to look forward to what OCHO or TO would do after a score cause they had good imaginations, and it was all done in the spirit of the game and to amuse the fans, not to show up anyone(forgive TO and the Cowboy star thing lol)

by mvs2417 on Jul 28, 2009 6:13 AM EDT reply actions  

Is a fine necessary?

Really? They are getting paid to do what they love and are passionate about. That’s why teams draft them. Thats why we have teams. Thats’ why we have the NFL. That’s why Roger Goddell has a job. When is enough enough? You are already killing yourself on the field and on camera. Might as well have fun. We put them in the public eye and tell them to act accordingly when the whole thing is a hypocrasy.

by Mosiah on Jul 28, 2009 10:35 AM EDT reply actions  

I agree

I mean, when I get an A on a college paper, I get excited, might do a victory arm pump, or let out a loud “YES!”… I don’t think there is anything wrong with celebrating when you accomplish something.

Scoring a touchdown when you are down by 28 points isn’t accomplishing anything.

Scoring the first touchdown of the game, or any touchdown that puts your team in the lead merits celebration.

I don’t think planned props are necessary, but if you have a football available to use as a prop, go for it? right?

know what you believe in and why you believe in it

by MentallyMIA on Jul 28, 2009 11:25 AM EDT up reply actions  

but still who doesnt love the excitement and fun of a td celebration

some players thats the only thing there remembered for i think celebrations should only be allowed in the endzone or after a turnover or a play of longer than 30 yards not counting return team and i think it should be on the ref’s call wether or not its being taken to far in that case fans get memories players dont get there feelings hurt and that brings up another good point do you think the other team really cares matter of fact recently other teams love to see the celebration for the the penalty they practically beg for it there proffessionals they dont care

by mistab50 on Jul 28, 2009 1:17 PM EDT reply actions  

Why Doesn't The NFL Celebrate Player Celebrations?

I personally think that those who try and justify the stifling of the players withathat tired addage “Try and act like you’ve been there before” are those who never played football at any level. There is nothing, and I mean NOTHING, harder than scoring a touchdown with 11 people physically trying to stop you. First comes the actual act of making an NFL roster. Ridiculously difficult. Become a starter, and keep your job, harder still. Stay healthy, and then “matriculate the ball down the field” (Thanks Coach Stram!) When a player scores it is the result of a fantastic team effort, often punctuated by a stupendous individual effort. The crowd tends to love it, at least gets a kick out of it. Tell me that people would rather hear Chris Collingsworthless, or any other announcer whine and complain about an endzone celebration. The reason he doesn’t like it is because he so rarely got there. It’s taking place during a stoppage of play and it draws fans to the game, particularly non-passionate females. They tend to find at least something humorous in it, and as a result they will watch, at least a little bit more. And that is definitely a win-win situation for guys everywhere.

To the point of showing up the other team, or being disrespectful, this is FOOTBALL !!! If there is something occurring that you don’t like, like getting run on for 300 yards, do something about it ! Like play some defense, like score more points. It’s SUPPOSED TO HURT AND BE DISRESPECTFUL, ITS A BEATDOWN !!! Get up! Be men! Do something! Anything! The team that scores has EARNED the right to gloat. Think back to when you were little kids playing in the street, sandlot, or churchyard, the phrase after scoring was, (all together now), “Loser walks!” Why do you think there are cheerleaders? To rub it in the face of the visiting team that they have more support than the other team.

Again, this is football, not baseball, where they have the stupid idea that you can’’t “show up” a pitcher after taking him 440 feet to straight-away centerfield, to tie the game or put it away. The solution is, rather punk-as*, that you throw at the next batter. Real good idea that. Try not throwing a hanging curve! Or a meatball down the middle. Again rather than being little beeatches, curled up in the fetal position, waiting for their mommies to powder their collective bottoms, do something about it. Play smarter, play better!

Football is a physical game designed to allow for backing up a team’s (and by extension a community’s) desire to BEAT the other team. Don’t you see? Without celebrating, trash talk, cheerleading, pep-rallies, fund-raisers, pranks, etc. there would be no rivalries. No one would care. I’m from Tennessee, love the Vols, and I played golf today with a Florida Gator fan. And we both had a classically good time ribbing each other about our teams. That is the essence of competition. Hence the phrase, “To the victor goes the spoils.”
If you want to take all the fun out of the greatest game there is, you’ll end up with futbol. Gee won’t that be fun?

by Al-dair Ven Kahn on Jul 29, 2009 12:51 AM EDT reply actions  

IMO, Sportsmanship...

matters more than winning. Be a good person. Then be a good football player.

by TomQ on Jul 29, 2009 8:54 AM EDT up reply actions  

Why stop it?

This is a game! It can pay millions, yes, so it’s a business. However, it is still a game. Unless the celebration is disrepectful like standing in the middle of the field on the other teams logo, celebrating should be allowed. As far as not celebrating after each play. Again, it is a game! Also, who doesn’t get excited when they accomplish something? In this game/business, you are judged based upon your PLAY. So by making a good PLAY, you are building your investment. If you make good plays, then, generally, you get paid. If you don’t make enough plays, then you don’t get paid. What businessperson, doesn’t get excited when scoring a new business deal or improving an existing one? I’m getting tired of the society we live in and the incompetence that runs free.

Most people who have issues with celebrations are people who don’t have an athletic bone in there body. Since no selected them to play sandlot football, they want to take it out on those of us who were good enough to play. All it takes is one play to get hurt and your career is over. So every play that you are on the field should be celebrated (whether you actually made the play or not LOL). I truly believe that.

If you have ever worked you butt off for years to accomplish something and finally get it, I guarantee you won’t just smile and walk off the field. But most people out were given opportunities and didn’t earn it. So those people would naturally have issues with people who worked hard and make it. Let the people who actually worked hard celebrate when they see their hardwork pay off even if it is one play. I guarantee that if any of you that object to celebrations actually got a sack or made a tackle, you would cheer, jump for joy, or maybe even hit a flip!!! I guarantee it!

by THE ICON KING E on Jul 29, 2009 4:41 PM EDT reply actions  

I don't think anyone is against...

…a fist pump or jump for joy, etc. It’s the “excessive celebrations” that are the issue – premeditated and showy. I don’t think that’s a fair generalization to say that most people who have issues with celebrations aren’t athletes.

by TomQ on Jul 30, 2009 8:53 AM EDT up reply actions  

By The Way!!!

MIKE VICK IS FREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

by THE ICON KING E on Jul 29, 2009 4:41 PM EDT reply actions  

Last I heard,

He wanted at least $9 million to return to football…so “free” might be a slight understatement.

You have opinions. Share them.

by Adam Schultz on Jul 29, 2009 7:29 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A Falcoholic Primer

Where Falcons fans come to roost.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Baron Of All He Blogs

Thefalcoholic_small Dave Choate

Marquis of Musings

Newprofile_small Adam Schultz

Earls of Typing

181614_735189801813_23210129_40578364_6784501_n_small Jason Kirk

Bear-woodsjpg-ee4252752e478b73_large_small James Rael

205892_10150259660296336_683626335_7946790_3837839_n_small Caleb Rutherford

Img_0301_small Jeanna Thomas