A Tale Of The Atlanta Falcons And A Quest For Perfection
Always live up to your standards - by lowering them, if necessary.
~Mignon McLaughlin
This whole L.J. Smith mess had me thinking about expectations yesterday. The truth is, most of us spend our lives trying to perfect one thing or another. When we do, we're usually greeted with a new set of expectations from everyone we know, until eventually we fall short of those lofty standards--at least temporarily--and we have to deal with failure. It's not a pleasant part of life, but most of us will hit a wall we can't climb.
I fear that we're beginning to set up a bit of a wall for the Atlanta Falcons this season, long before the draft has begun. After a single 11-5 season that featured a luck of excellent scouting, great play and sheer luck, many (myself very much included) have anointed Thomas Dimitroff as our savior and built altars to Matt Ryan and Michael Turner. It's kind of natural for fans of a success-starved franchise, I think, but I'm increasingly realizing what kind of trap we're putting ourselves in here.
I truly believe that the Falcons have a long-term plan. Do I think that plan is going to feature a playoff appearance this year? After watching the team repeatedly pass on free agents and target low-to-mid level guys instead, after watching them let go of several key defensive players and team leaders, I'm not sure that's something we should write down on our stone tablets. It's telling that this off-season has been so unbelievably quiet that L.J. Smith's team-tease has consumed the collective time and energy of this site for the last couple of weeks. We're going to re-build our shaky defense mostly through the draft, and that approach rarely yields immediate results. If you don't count last season, that is.
That isn't to say that the Falcons can't achieve great things in the season ahead, and I'd be a pretty foolish and handsome blogger to pick against them blowing away the rest of the NFC South. I just think that we'd be wise to temper our expectations a little bit for this next year, especially if it helps us achieve sustained success instead of the kind of one-year wonder that comes with loading up on expensive free agents. Some of the great dynasties in sports have built through smart drafts and clever signings, and as a former Patriots personnel man, Dimitroff is well aware of that.
Now that you've read this far, get in your nominations for round two of our mock draft! After a news roundup tomorrow, we'll be starting that sucker back up on Thursday.
28 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I'm with Dave on this one
I wonder as well if we’ve set our sights a little too high. Don’t get me wrong, I believe that our team will perform well, and will (hopefully) contend in every game. But we have a lot of factors to consider. We have lost several (by my quick count 6? correct me if I’m wrong it’s early still) Defensive starters, who while slowing, played key roles in our playoff run (and early departure) last year. I’m a big fan of the direction our defense is going, but to quote Bobby Cox via FrankyWren “[we’re] getting better, but [we’re] not quite there yet.” We need another solid draft (or two) to really solidify this team on both offense and defense.
Let’s look at another factor that will play into our success next year. Health. Specifically dealing with two players: Abraham and Turner. Abraham was dinged up all last year but still put on a clinic (unfortunately it was a clinic that J. Anderson didn’t pay attention to). Turner played solid. And by solid, I mean he was everything we hoped for and more. The performance of Turner this year really was surprising to me. It was like when Dave as for a My Little Pony for Christmas and a real one showed up Christmas Day. The only thing that worries me about that though is that Turner got those 1,699 yards on 376 carries. That’s more touches than T.O. can shake a stick at. Part of the reason for this (I believe) is the rib injury that Norwood suffered earlier on in the season. That put more of a load on the substantial tackle breaking shoulders of the Burner. Turner’s staying healthy is, I would argue, the number 1 factor to our continued success. Because who do we have behind him? Norwood? I love the guy, bought the jersey, all that jazz, but he can’t handle (IMO) a 200 carry season. Snelling? Does anyone believe him to be a solid starter? Thomas Brown? I don’t have much faith after him being on IR last year. If Turner goes down, I fear that our season will be in trouble. Not to put anything past Matty Ice and his insane throws in the face of pressure.
With Abraham, I think we all saw what happened when he wasn’t in the game. And the result was hardly pretty. Usually it resulted in 1st downs in passing situations because there was no pressure. Chauncey started to play well in limited playing time, but J. Anderson, while solid against the run, couldn’t sack Byron Leftwich in the pocket when he was playing with a shattered ankle and he had a clear path.
The main thing that makes me a little nervous, though, is our schedule. Besides playing the NFC South twice (of course) we also face Philadelphia (H), Dallas (A), Washington (H), and the New York Football Giants (A) from the NFC East, and then Buffalo (H), New England (A), Miami (H), and the Jets (A). Add into that equation Da Bears (H) and the 49’s (A) and we are looking at a pretty tough schedule. 3 playoff teams. 5 teams that were above .500, 1 team at .500, and 2 teams that went 7-9. And that is not counting the NFC South.
So all I want to say, is that while I am optimistic, I am reserving my right to shout out all the reasons why we should pick who we pick in the draft (like I did with Ryan, thank the maker I’m not the GM). I think a little skepticism is needed here. If we go 9-7 I’ll be very happy. If we win the division, I’ll be making bold, beer induced statements about feats that neither man nor beast could possibly do. But before that happens, I’m going to hunker down. Be cautiously optimistic. And make fun of Dave for asking for a “My Little Pony” for Christmas.
As always, be smart, be responsible, and always
Pregame with Pabst
If my mother put on a helmet and shoulder pads and a uniform that wasn't the same as the one I was wearing, I'd run over her if she was in my way. And I love my mother.
-Bo Jackson
by Pregame with Pabst on Mar 17, 2009 9:12 AM EDT reply actions
Couldn't agree more ...
The dreaded “injury bug” could take us out of contention entirely (if the right guys go down).
Oh, and PBR is the shaz.
"He's getting better, but he's not there yet ..."
- Bobby Cox (talking about Boyer)
How. Dare. You.
I don’t mock your fascination with flight attendant Barbie, do I?
by Dave Choate on Mar 17, 2009 10:10 AM EDT up reply actions
Yes
PBR is the shaz. The original shaz in my opinion. Blue Ribbon is where its at.
And, Dave, I can’t help it with the Barbie fascination. I have a thing for older women made of plastic.
If my mother put on a helmet and shoulder pads and a uniform that wasn't the same as the one I was wearing, I'd run over her if she was in my way. And I love my mother.
-Bo Jackson
by Pregame with Pabst on Mar 17, 2009 11:19 AM EDT up reply actions
We're due a small step back, absolutely.
The 2008 schedule was PERFECT for this team. Chiefs, Raiders, Rams, Lions, etc. You couldn’t ask for better matchups for a young, rebuilding team.
Now we’ve replaced them with the Patriots, Cowboys, Eagles, Giants, Jets and Redskins. I don’t want to say 11-5 is out of the question – but, well…
The thing is, we can take a step back as far as our record, but still step forward. Nine wins could take the NFC South. I don’t believe the Panthers will be as good this year, the Saints could be anywhere between 4-12 and 12-4, and the Bucs shouldn’t present any real threat. If we can get into the playoffs at 9-7 or 10-6, with perhaps confidence building wins against a couple of the big boys listed above, our playoff run could be deeper.
This is a copy and paste more or less (from one of my previous posts) ...
I’d like to see the Birds pick the best two-gap-type run stuffer in the second round, and Peria Jerry doesn’t fit that bill in my opinion (read: the opinion of a lot of scouts).
Maybe Al Woods out of LSU. He’s a big boy (6’4 and 315 lbs), but he has respectable speed (has run the 40 in the 5.1ish range).
Ron Brace (the other BC DT) would be a nice pickup as well. First of all, he’s HUGE (dude is pushing 340). He’s not a pass rusher, but he’ll be able to occupy multiple blockers in his rookie season, which would bode well for our DEs.
"He's getting better, but he's not there yet ..."
- Bobby Cox (talking about Boyer)
Oh yeah?!
The vision: Coming off an incredible 11-5 season (achieved during a “rebuilding” year) the Atlanta Falcons have nowhere to go but up. A Super Bowl appearance is not far away.
The naked truth: This is the NFL. Free Agency and Contract Terms rule the roost, and with the Salary Cap (shakily) in place, teams do not have the buying power required to build powerhouse dynasties.
Despite this, some franchises have been able to work through these limitations and create lasting dynasties in an environment unfriendly to legacy building. The Pittsburgh Steelers come to mind, especially seeing that they were able to return to (and win) the Super Bowl despite a coaching regime change and major FA/Retirement losses. The other team that comes to mind? The New England Patriots.
The Patriots built their three-ring team through a reliance on smart draft picks and even smarter FA pickups. The Patriots were draft heavy and that’s where a lot of their skill came from. This is more than evident when one considers that Tom Brady’s backup, who hadn’t thrown a ball in regulation since high school, was able to jump right in and start winning. The Pat scouts know their stuff.
The good news: One of those scouts is now our GM. What he was able to accomplish in year one is more than anyone, regardless of how optimistic and, bluntly-put, retarded they were, could have expected. It was an instant return on the investment made by Mr. Blank. What this means for us is that we have a draft-first, FA-later personnel mentality. Dimitroff knew that he could get Ryan. He didn’t know whether he would be able to get a good running back (or, he didn’t see one available that could do what he wanted), so he goes to FA. He picks up Turner. The rest is history.
We have our Tom Brady. We have our LT. Now we need our Urlacher/Lewis. And friends, it isn’t going to come from FA. Neither is the ball-hocking TE Matty Ice wants. They’re going to come via the draft.
The bad news: This is the NFL. An injury can ruin a season. Mr. Burner carried 376 times last year. That’s unprecedented. That’s nigh ridiculous. I am utterly amazed that he was not down at least for a game. Regardless of his durability, he cannot continue to take that many carries and remain uninjured.
The hope: This is Matt Ryan’s second year in the league. Last season, he went from ok, to good, to amazing in the span of 13 or so games. We all have a lot of expectations for him. Mine is merely that he improves his game. Improve, you may ask? How can Matty Ice improve? Well, for starters, he can widen the ratio between his TDs and INTs by increasing his defensive recognition. With a year behind his belt that included a playoff appearance, he can start to iron up his stomach and make better decisions under pressure. I personally believe he will do this and that the team will slowly shift to a more balanced run/pass offense.
My other hope lies solely with our scouts, GM, and coach. The defense needs rebuilding and I do honestly trust them to do a good job of it. The only issue stems from the question whether or not they can repeat their offensive success last year with the defense this year. And in that question resides a lot of uncertainty. Will we turn our defense into a powerhouse? I don’t think so. I think the rebuild needs this draft and the next to be complete.
So until I build a wall I can’t scale or destroy the garden fence I’m currently refurbishing, I’m going to see how our draft goes. Then I’ll build or demolish as necessary.
"If the Falcons ever manage to win a Super Bowl in my lifetime, I'll french kiss a toilet." - a friend.
What will the draft tell you?
After last year’s draft several “fans” were disappointed with our picks (see the Falconholic archives) and look how they turned out. Conversely many of us, myself included, were thrilled when we drafted J. Anderson.
The draft is a like a box of chocolates, brother. Build or demolish now. Why wait?
Falcon Fans UNITE!
by Blue Falcon on Mar 17, 2009 12:26 PM EDT up reply actions
The draft will tell me one important thing:
whether or not the administration is trying to build up our defense. If they do, I’ll be optimistic.
If they take offensive players that are not TEs, I’ll be disappointed, especially considering the defensive players we lost.
So, in short, the draft will tell me whether TD plans to build a defense now that he has an offense or if he prefers to just bolster the offense and leave our defense to struggle.
My guess is the former.
"If the Falcons ever manage to win a Super Bowl in my lifetime, I'll french kiss a toilet." - a friend.
by Adam Schultz on Mar 17, 2009 12:46 PM EDT up reply actions
Anyone remember
the “Lowered Expectations” skits from the old Mad TV show?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRcj9WbHLjk
"When I played pro football, I never set out to hurt anyone deliberately - unless it was, you know, important, like a league game or something"
-Dick Butkus
Good times all around
Do any of you watch SNL? The Bill Hader Dateline sketch is rapidly becoming one of my favorites.
by Dave Choate on Mar 17, 2009 12:49 PM EDT up reply actions
The NFL is a Crazy Place
And no division is more crazy than the NFC South. But unlike the rest of the teams in our division (with the exception of maybe the Panthers), we’re ahead of the curve in building a foundation. For years the Saints and Bucs have been building plug and play teams, taking Veterans to try to solidify their defense (for the Saints) and the offense (for the Bucs). The Panthers are really the only team that built a sustained successful unit, and they did it mostly in the same way we’re starting, the draft.
Now here’s the point, we’re ahead of the curve on most of the teams in the NFC South. Our offense, aside from one position, is pretty much set, the only thing we need to worry about there is building depth. TD is doing the smart thing here, and he’s scouting and filling the defense with talent through the cheapest means possible. Further, he’s got faith in the coaching staff to turn that talent into a mean cohesive unit.
Seriously, I think you’re probably looking at a plan that was phase 1: get a successful running offense first, then add balance with a passing attack. That phase was achieved faster than anyone thought, and it helped us hide a relatively weak defense. Phase 2: Rebuild the defense to stop the run and get pressure up front. Phase 3: Add the finishing touches for a sustained unit and just keep adding depth.
We’re all worried about the immediate results, but this is the smartest decision for a franchise, that is for once, on the same page from top to bottom. That’s why I have a lot of faith in the plan. Keep in mind, it’s a “process” and we just saw the first phase of “the process.”
it was a very accelerated 1st phase
Even good ol’ Smitty said so himself. He never foresaw the progression of the team to take place so rapidly. Fortunately for us, it did. I think as fans, we are allowed to have high expectations at this point and our trust in this coaching staff is very easily justified.
I am very confident that whatever happens at this point, I will always be a proud Falcon fan. Last season, I was ready to cheer for my team when I was convinced that our team was going to win 4 games or less, allowing myself to celebrate whenever we happened to creep into a shortly held lead. I’m glad I was very wrong. That is why I am glad to go into this season predicting my team is going to get 9 wins and make Falcons Franchise history… if they don’t… it will be back to my mental drawing board that means nothing to anybody but my fellow fans.
I really don’t think our defense has as many holes as it appears to have (at least not in our coaching staff’s eyes). There are obvious needs on our front 7, but I think that Thomas DeCoud, Erik Coleman and possibly even Chevis Jackson are going to be very surprising in this up-coming year.
Second round draft choice
Well I’m sure everyone knows who I’d like in the first round…
As for 2nd, I’d like to address the safety position with William Moore if he’s still hanging around. The draft is pretty deep as far as plug run stuffers. 3rd round or 4th round that position should be addressed. If not , we’ll sign some free agent after cuts are made before the season.
The Falcons are looking for a Big man 300+ that can plug the middle and possibly take on two blockers. It’s not going to make a bit of difference, if we still have no one to rush the passer. Without Abraham in the lineup, the Falcons have absolutely no threating personnel on defense.
"Just want the Falcons to win a bowl before I'm gone!"
by Edgecrusher211 on Mar 17, 2009 8:08 PM EDT up reply actions
pass rushing LB
Sintim…anyway you look at it…it just works.
Paired beside Lofton for years? hell yeah
"Just want the Falcons to win a bowl before I'm gone!"
by Edgecrusher211 on Mar 17, 2009 10:13 PM EDT up reply actions
I'm w/ you on taking a S as early as possible ...
but I think a big, capable, offensive linemen-occupying DT could have a bigger impact than you think.
It’s not going to make a bit of difference, if we still have no one to rush the passer
The more OL our DTs can occupy, the less OL our DEs have to contend w/. Maybe I’m oversimplifying this, and you’re absolutely right when you say that there are A LOT of capable DTs in this draft, but I’m not sure we can afford to draft a “project” in the third or fourth rounds. In other words, I think we should go DT as soon as it’s prudent to do so. If that’s in the second round, so be it. Coleman/DeCoud scares me a lot less than Babs/Lewis or Jefferson or Anderson (if they move him inside) or Moorehead.
"He's getting better, but he's not there yet ..."
- Bobby Cox (talking about Boyer)
No Projects
I agree! I’m a fan of drafting someone that can play the position. No so much for drafting athletic players with potential. The Falcons have really never pursued a DT early in the draft, unless you look at Babs. I like Babs, but I cant see him paired with someone like Jerry. I think I’ve heard Smith say that he’d like a defense built like the Ravens. If that’s the case, the Ravens thrive with their linebackers and Secondary. The Falcons could pick up DT’s Hill, Marks, Scott in the later rounds and concentrate on LB’s or Secondary early.
"Just want the Falcons to win a bowl before I'm gone!"
by Edgecrusher211 on Mar 18, 2009 7:09 AM EDT up reply actions
Expectations should be tempered
The coaches and fans can call it whatever they want to call it, but the reality is that this team is right in the middle of a lengthy rebuilding process. Last season, as unmitigatingly, mind alteringly awecreditastic as it was, really didn’t look to me like it was played by a team built for immediate, sustained success. There were still a lot of positions, notably on defense, that were held together by duct tape, and other positions that were manned by players who were actively trying to rip that tape off (Keith F’ing Brooking). I don’t want to say that last season’s record was an anomaly, but there is a reason the Falcons were picked to be so bad. This year, the team will have several positions that will be manned by young or unproven players who will be learning by diving head first into a tough NFL schedule. There are bound to be growing pains. However, even if the team slips back to .500 or worse, there is no cause for worry. Last season showed that the team is in good hands at key positions, on the sidelines, and in the front office. Young players who will be relied on heavily this year got valuable playing experience. An 11-5 season may have proven that the growth of the Falcons may not take as long as we thought, but that doesn’t mean that the team has matured fully quite yet. This is not a team being built to win next season. It is being built to succeed in the next one. And the one after that. And the one after that…
BEST DESCRIPTION EVER
mind alteringly awecreditastic
"He's getting better, but he's not there yet ..."
- Bobby Cox (talking about Boyer)
FUTURE
I HAVE BEEN KEEPING UP WITH AND WATCHING THE FALCONS SINCE THEIR INCEPTION IN 1966. I FEEL BETTER ABOUT THIS MANAGEMENT TEAM THAN I EVER HAVE. I FELT BRIEFLY GOOD ABOUT LEEMAN AND REEVES, BUT THAT PEAK DIDN’T LAST. I THINK THESE GUYS ARE BUILDING LONG TERM. WHAT WE DON’T SEE IS TD’S PLAN FOR 2010 AND 2011 WHICH HAS TO BE (AND SHOULD BE) DRIVING HIS DECISIONS FOR THIS YEAR. HE HAS ELECTED NOT TO HEAVILY PURSUE FREE AGENTS THIS YEAR WHEN HE COULD, BUT TRUST THAT THERE IS A LONG TERM REASON FOR THAT. LOOK AT HOW DECISIVE HE WAS LAST YEAR IN FREE AGENCY. HE IS NOT GOING TO CHANGE STRATEGY THAT DRASTICALLY WITHOUT FIRM LOGIC.
I AM VERY RELIEVED THAT WE DID NOT SIGN THE PHILLIE TE. I HOPE THAT WE DON’T DRAFT PETTIGREW IN THE FIRST ROUND. BUT AS THE TE POSITION IS DEEP THIS YEAR, I WOULDN’T BE SURPRISED IF WE TAKE ONE LATER. LOOK FOR ON ROSTER GUYS TO STEP UP AND THE GAPS TO BE FILLED IN THE DRAFT. WE MAY NOT MAKE THE PLAYOFFS, BUT I THINK THE REAL GOAL SHOULD BE TO HAVE BACK TO BACK WINNING SEASONS FOR THE FIRST TIME IN FALCON HISTORY!!!!!!!! IF THEY DO THAT, AND I THINK THEY WILL, AND THEY CONTINUE TO BUILD LONG TERM, WHICH I THINK THEY WILL, THEY I WILL BE VERY HAPPY. IF WE MAKE THE PLAYOFFS, SO MUCH THE BETTER,
THE WHOPPER
I agree with pretty much everything you've said here
One small request. Can you take it off of caps log next time out? Thanks man.
by Dave Choate on Mar 17, 2009 11:31 PM EDT up reply actions
1966?
Dang … that was 19 years before I was born, so it’s interesting for me to hear your take.
When Leeman/Reeves were running the show, what moves did you question? To that effect, what moves were you thrilled w/?
"He's getting better, but he's not there yet ..."
- Bobby Cox (talking about Boyer)
I remember Leeman
I had barely put away my Tonka truck when Bennett got hired so I didn’t really question him but I remember a fair percentage of fans were happy to see him go because he couldn’t win consistently. If I remember, the thinking was Glanville was the mastermind behind our defense (a premise I can’t even fathom without throwing up in my mouth a little) before he took off to be HC with the Oilers and our offense was predictable and plodding. As I recall some people thought Bennett just didn’t get the rule changes that went into effect back then (no chucking the reciever after 5 yards, etc) and a more wide-open, aggressive style of play was the only way to go.
Of course, a lot of people also thought June Jones should have started over Bartkowski too…
"When I played pro football, I never set out to hurt anyone deliberately - unless it was, you know, important, like a league game or something"
-Dick Butkus

by 


















