Dorsey Is A Trainwreck Waiting To Happen
ENOUGH!
The lamenting about the Falcons taking Ryan at three has got to stop.
Sure, Dorsey is quick and he has a great first step, but there are some serious questions about his long-term durability. Some will balk and point to the fact that he played injured throughout his entire senior campaign. I understand that most of the players in the NFL play through some sort of nagging injury week in and week out. But, what if the leg is an issue? I am just saying, IT COULD BE AN ISSUE. He chose not to go pro after his junior year because he felt that teams were looking at him as a liability, someone they weren't sure could stay healthy. Yeah he played injured all last year, but he was trying to prove something. Similarly, Ryan COULD be the next 1st round QB bust. Or, he COULD be the next Carson Palmer, but better.
Bottom line: We don't know how well these guys are going to do. We can guess that Dorsey will kick some serious butt. But what if he doesn't? What if his hammy and shin injuries are still affecting him? What if he is double teamed all year (something he struggles with) and he works out about as well as J-Mal Anderson. Or, what if he can't vary his repertoire? I mean, the dude is known for having one move. How long is it going to take NFL lineman to figure him out. I see him as a Warren Sapp at best, but I see Ryan as someone who could be very good in this league as well.
Maybe Dorsey will be a hall of famer. But MAYBE, just maybe, he won't. Maybe he'll have a few brilliant moments in between several weeks on IR. Then, MAYBE we'll all be able to get over the Ryan pick.
0 recs |
9
comments
| Add your comment
Comments
I agree
What’s done is done people. It’s time to just move forward with you have. Like my Dad used to say:
“When life gives you lemons, you make 3-13 seasons”
....or something like that.
In a way, each of us has an El Guapo to face.
by runningback on
May 6, 2008 5:12 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
Once again
Dorsey got hurt because of a Code Red courtesy of Tommy Tubberville. Its not like it just happened, a hit got put out on his knee. I really don’t think you can hold that against him and chalk it up as a “durability” issue. But whatever. He isn’t a Falcon, which means I really don’t care.
by SG Standard on
May 6, 2008 6:54 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
Um, okay...Apparently you aren't big on logic
You are saying that I can’t hold his injury against him because he didn’t deserve to be injured. I don’t care whether he is at fault for his injury. I am saying that he is injured and his production will likely be affected by his injuries. I’m not sure where you lost me. But you did.
"You never know what I'm going to do..."
- Michael Vick (Palm Beach Post 11/6/2005)
by jamesrael on
May 6, 2008 7:14 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
No, heres what I'm saying
This isnt an injury that happened when he was chasing down a QB or fighting off a block. It happened because somebody tried to injure him. That one injury does make him injury prone. If it had happened while he was just walking to the huddle or doing a drill at practice, that is one thing. Getting hurt (and managing to play through it for half the season, btw) because someone went directly for your knee isnt on the same level. Yeah, you can guess that it might affect his production, but if it were bad enough to turn him into a trainwreck, he wouldnt have gone at #5. He probably went through an unimaginable number of tests leading up to the draft. Something that serious would have most likely been caught.
by SG Standard on
May 7, 2008 8:24 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Let me try this again...
I never said he was “injury prone.” I SAID he has a past injury that I believe will affect his productivity. Not just this year, rather, in the long-term. Moreover, although he has been the target of some infamous chop and double-team blocks, he explained the injury to his leg happened in the weight room. Look it up if you don’t believe me. The dude had to wear a device designed to stimulate bone growth for 18 hours a day. How did he deal with the injury? He took painkillers before every game. Not just advil, prescription painkillers. Sans the medical device and the painkillers, I doubt he’d have played in every game. How did he deal with the injury? He took painkillers before every game. Not just advil, prescription painkillers. Also, the NFL docs at the combine were concerned enough about their initial tests to send him to the hospital for further testing. So, for you to say that if there was something there, they would have caught it, it just proves you are missing the obvious here. First, they did catch it. They caught it and they made him go for further testing. Second, so what if a team took a chance on him? I agree he has a huge upside. But with a bum leg, I feel like his durability is going to be an issue. It’d be different if his nagging injury problems didn’t have to do with his legs. Why? Because they are his bread and butter. Without his lower body, he is nothing. Look at any one of the draft reports that were put out about him, they all say the same thing I am saying. Finally, let me just reiterate, I am not saying his injury is all is fault. I am saying that his injury is there and I am glad we weren’t the ones to take a chance on him.
"You never know what I'm going to do..."
- Michael Vick (Palm Beach Post 11/6/2005)
by jamesrael on
May 7, 2008 9:03 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Ahh...reminds me of....
2006 Draft, Houston Texans, First Overall Pick.
Reggie Bush, the All-American wonder kid who was going to “re-define” the running back position someday.
Vince Young, the next (gulp) Michael Vick.
And then we have Mario Williams.
The Texans fans lamented the team for not drafting Bush or Vince Young and look how that scenario has panned out.
Time heals all pains (2007) and time tells which decisions are good or bad.
by jjestes on
May 7, 2008 1:12 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
Wait and See
We will get to see first hand the 3rd game of the season what type of player Dorsey will become! Matty Ice will probably sit for the first 8-10 games, but we will probably not really see how he developes until next season. But to dump on Dorsey prematurely for imagined reasons is really classless. Lets just wait and see how both players develop.
by remoley on
May 8, 2008 8:50 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
"Warren Sapp at best"
Yeah, that kind of counters your whole argument. Warren Sapp was the best DT in the game for a decade. No one could stop him until he was in the last years of his career and even then it was a very demanding and difficult thing to do. One could only hope for Dorsey to end up being like Sapp and if he does then that would just prove that we made a mistake in passing on him.
The injury argument is a weightless one because that is the only time he has had any issues whatsoever. To justify that you would have to argue that about every single player in the draft as they have all had something in the past. Then no one would get drafted because every player would have an injury issue that may affect their future productivity.
The argument for Dorsey over Ryan isn’t one of 100% future productivity but more one of who was the most ready and able to make an immediate impact, one which clearly Dorsey would win. Also, the relative lack of quality DT’s and the absurd abundance of quality QB’s should have been an obvious enough reason to take Dorsey over Ryan.
I do believe that everyone is entitled to their opinion but I have to say that your comments are fairly arrogant, condescending, and plain rude, which surely isn’t helping your argument at all. There are more people who are upset with the teams draft than not and they are going to express that. And yes, they will move on just like all fans do, just as you must move on with them being upset about it.
by Jesse28 on
May 12, 2008 3:39 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
MISSING THE POINT
I don’t care whether Dorsey has more potential. I agree with you. He has enormous potential. In fact, he could be a Warren Sapp. Alternatively, he could suck it up. The Comrade, Smith, and Blank made a decision based on what they had in front of them. I may not agree. You may not agree. But they made a decision. It’s a decision I am willing to accept and I am excited to see how Ryan does. Maybe he will be horrible. Then, five years down the line, you can look back and laugh. For now, Matt Ryan is a Falcon and Glenn Dorsey is not. So, instead of pretending like I am qualified to be a GM, I will keep my criticism to a minimum and MOVE ON. Oh, and I still think you have issues.
"You never know what I'm going to do..."
- Michael Vick (Palm Beach Post 11/6/2005)
by jamesrael on
May 12, 2008 3:58 PM EDT
up
reply
0 recs







